News

Maryland Prediction Market Ruling: States Win Again, Supreme Court Looms

The Fourth Circuit says Maryland can police sports prediction markets, deepening a split headed for the Supreme Court. Here's what it means for bettors.

L
Lemmy Bookiezz
November 21, 2026 · Updated Nov 21, 2026
⏱ 5 min read 👁️ 4 views

The legal fight over sports prediction markets just tilted further toward the states. In the Maryland prediction market ruling handed down this week, a divided federal appeals court said Maryland can enforce its gambling laws against a prediction-market operator that has been offering sports event contracts to people in the state without a sports wagering licence.

It is the third federal appeals court to side with a state, against one that went the other way. That split all but guarantees the Supreme Court will have the final word. If you’ve been trading game outcomes on a prediction-market app rather than betting them at a sportsbook, here’s what happened and what it means for you.

The ruling: The US Court of Appeals for the Fourth Circuit voted 2-1 on Tuesday, November 17, 2026, to uphold a lower court’s refusal to block Maryland’s regulators from enforcing state gambling law against a prediction-market operator.

The scoreboard: Three federal appeals courts (the Fourth, Sixth and Ninth Circuits) have now sided with the states. One, the Third Circuit in a New Jersey case, has sided with the operator.

MyBookie
★ 8.2/10 Read review
Welcome offer50% Free Play up to $1,000
Join MyBookie →18+ · New players · T&Cs apply

What the Court Actually Decided

The dispute goes back to 2025, when Maryland’s gaming regulator ordered the operator to stop offering sports contracts in the state. The company sued, arguing that its contracts are federally regulated derivatives that only the Commodity Futures Trading Commission can police, under the Commodity Exchange Act. In August 2025 a federal judge refused to grant the preliminary injunction the operator wanted, letting Maryland’s enforcement go ahead for now (Maryland Daily Record).

The Fourth Circuit has now affirmed that decision. Two things about it matter:

  • It is not the end of the case. The appeals court only upheld the denial of a preliminary injunction. Maryland’s enforcement case goes back to the district court, where the operator can still try to win on the merits.
  • It is a splintered decision. The three judges wrote three separate opinions and did not agree on the core question of whether sports event contracts count as “swaps” under federal law (Courthouse News). The dissenting judge would have sided with the operator.

Maryland’s regulator welcomed the ruling as confirmation that the state can regulate what it considers sports wagering, and said it was weighing its next steps. The operator argued that three contradictory opinions show there is no coherent legal case against prediction markets (Baltimore Sun, CBS Baltimore).

The Circuit Split, in One Table

When federal appeals courts disagree on the same question of federal law, the Supreme Court usually steps in. Here is where the main cases stand (CNBC covered the Sixth Circuit decision).

Appeals courtState in the caseSided with
Fourth CircuitMaryland✓ The state (2-1, Nov 2026)
Sixth CircuitOhio and Tennessee✓ The states (3-0, Sep 2026)
Ninth CircuitNevada✓ The state (Aug 2026)
Third CircuitNew Jersey✗ The operator (Apr 2026)

New Jersey’s regulators have already asked the Supreme Court to review the Third Circuit’s decision, according to coverage of this week’s ruling, and the Maryland case can be appealed there too. A decision from the justices would settle, for the whole country, whether states can treat sports event contracts as gambling.

ℹ

Why the swap question matters: If sports event contracts are federally regulated swaps, states may be unable to touch them, and prediction markets could offer game contracts in all 50 states, including those with no legal sports betting. If they aren’t, every state keeps control of sports wagering inside its borders, just as it does with sportsbooks today.

What It Means for Bettors

If you use prediction markets for sports

Expect access to keep changing state by state. The rulings so far allow states to enforce their gambling laws, so in Maryland and other states that win in court, the operators may have to geofence sports contracts or close them. If that happens while you hold an open position, check the platform’s own notices for how it will be settled. Maryland isn’t the only fight: the City of Baltimore has a separate consumer-protection lawsuit against two prediction-market operators.

If you’re weighing contracts against a sportsbook

A sports event contract and a moneyline bet are economically much the same thing: you pay a price and collect if the team wins. The differences are in the plumbing. Prediction markets match you against other traders and charge a fee per contract. A sportsbook builds its margin into the odds. Our guide to prediction market alternatives for betting compares the two in detail, including fees versus vig.

Taxes don’t change

Whatever you call it, a contract or a bet, profit from it is taxable income. Keep your own records, because platforms differ in what they report.

MyBookie

8.2
★★★★★★★★☆
Welcome Bonus
50% Free Play up to $1,000
₿Crypto
⚡Live Betting
✓ Top Pros
  • One of the biggest prop and novelty menus
  • Credit cards and crypto both work
  • Easy 10% cash bonus with a 1x rollover

Bovada

8.0
★★★★★★★★☆☆
Welcome Bonus
75% Crypto Match up to $750
₿Crypto
⚡Live Betting
✓ Top Pros
  • 5x Rollover
  • MatchPay
  • Underdog Value

BUSR

7.3
★★★★★★★☆☆
Welcome Bonus
100% up to $3,000 (3 Deposits)
₿Crypto
⚡Live Betting
✓ Top Pros
  • Bitcoin withdrawals
  • Racebook rebates
  • All 50 states allowed

What Happens Next

  • The Supreme Court. The biggest date to watch is whether, and when, the justices agree to hear one of these cases. It isn’t yet clear whether the Court will take a case now or wait for more circuits to rule.
  • The district court in Maryland. The Maryland case now returns to the trial court on the merits.
  • More states. Every state ruling makes it easier for other regulators to act, especially in states where sports betting is licensed and taxed and prediction markets compete with those licensed books.

For bettors in states like Texas and California, where sports betting has never been legalised, the outcome matters even more. Prediction markets have been one of the few domestic ways to trade on games there. Our guides to Texas sports betting sites and California sports betting sites explain the options in those states today.

⚠

No shortcuts: If a platform blocks sports contracts in your state, don’t try to get around the block. Platforms check location for legal reasons, and getting around those checks can get your account closed and your balance held.

Where to Bet Sports Instead

If you’d rather bet games the traditional way, MyBookie is our first pick, with full NFL, college and NBA markets and a welcome bonus. Bovada and BUSR are good second accounts for comparing prices. Bovada isn’t available in every state.

MyBookie
★ 8.2/10 Read review
Welcome offer50% Free Play up to $1,000
Claim the MyBookie bonus →18+ · New players · T&Cs apply

The legal side: the offshore sportsbooks we review are not licensed by any US state, and whether you can use one depends on the law where you live. Maryland residents can also use the state’s licensed sports betting apps. Winnings are taxable income, and you must be 21 or older in most states.

Whatever you bet on, set limits first. Our responsible gambling page has free resources, or call 1-800-GAMBLER.

Share this article:

Frequently Asked Questions

L
Lemmy Bookiezz
Betting Expert

Our team of betting experts provides independent, in-depth analysis of sportsbooks, odds, and betting strategies to help you make smarter wagering decisions.

More Guides You Might Like

Ready to Put Your Knowledge to Use?

Browse our expert sportsbook reviews and find your perfect betting platform

Browse Sportsbooks